Language machines, robotics and setting the course for a human future:
A critical examination with Simanowski and Schulte-Huermann
The world is increasingly permeated by algorithms and autonomous systems. Robots populate our factories and voice machines shape our communication. But while many celebrate efficiency and progress, an uncomfortable question arises: What does this development mean for us as humans, for our understanding of knowledge, creativity and identity? The media philosopher Roberto Simanowski has adopted a critical perspective in his works, particularly in "Language Machines", which forces us to take a closer look.
These philosophical warnings were taken up early on by practitioners such as Markus Schulte-Huermann. As early as 2023, when the general public could barely imagine the full force of generative AI, he asked the crucial question: "The future with AI: do we need to set the course now?" [[DOCREF:The_future_with_AI_must_we_set_the_course_now.pdf]]. His analysis underscores the urgency of Simanowski's concerns from a business and societal perspective. It is a warning against uncritical acceptance, which we must not ignore in the context of the rapid development of robotics and artificial intelligence.
The market for humanoid robots may grow to over $38 billion by 2035, with giants such as Tesla, Agility Robotics and Figure AI in the US, as well as NEURA Robotics in Germany and PAL Robotics in Spain, driving development [[DOCREF:humanoid_report_2026_v19-jwxa0v.pdf], [DOCREF:Lister der Robotoic-Hersteller.pdf], [DOCREF:portal-memory-humanoide roboter Hersteller europa-2026-01-13.pdf]].
Current developments in robotics (June 2026) underpin this urgency: Humanoid robots are rapidly advancing into everyday life. China is massively promoting their use in factories and has issued national guidelines to turn the sector into a new growth engine by 2027. NVIDIA has presented Isaac GR00T, an open reference design that is intended to accelerate commercialization. The cost of humanoid robots is falling dramatically (Chinese models are sometimes under USD 10,000) and they are increasingly being used in factories, warehouses and hospitals. There are reports of robots that can work autonomous 8-hour shifts or even run a half marathon. While Europe plays an important role as a supplier of sensors, drives and chips, large investments in companies such as Standard Bots and NEURA Robotics show the enormous growth potential. In parallel, research in AI and machine learning is progressing, with new open-source datasets to reduce the need for training data, concepts such as "Physical AI" and a focus on "Uncertainty Representation" in neural networks [[DOCREF:_user_Aktuelle_Entwicklungen_Robotik_Juni_2026.md]].
However, these figures and advances mask the real challenge: the increasing presence of machine-generated content and actions. When robots operate in complex environments, they encounter epistemic uncertainty - gaps in knowledge that they are unaware of [[DOCREF:A_Review_of_Uncertainty_Representation_a.pdf]]. But the deeper philosophical question that Simanowski raises, confirming Schulte-Huermann's early warnings, is: what happens to our epistemic certainty when we rely on systems that themselves do not know what they do not know, and whose "knowledge" is often only a statistical probability?
Philosophical and practical areas of tension: A dialectical consideration according to Simanowski and Schulte-Huermann
The discussion about AI and robotics is a battlefield of ideas. Simanowski forces us to critically question the supposed opportunities and to recognize the risks in their full philosophical scope. Schulte-Huermann's article from 2023 provides concrete, early warnings from the field.
| Source no. | Steelman (The supposedly strongest argument of the proponents) | Break it (Simanowski's smartest objection/the philosophical risk, confirmed by Schulte-Huermann) | Rebuild it (The merciless truth: A path to maturity) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | AI as a catalyst for new creativity: AI expands human creativity and enables new forms of expression, similar to the evolution of song over millennia. It serves as a tool that opens up new artistic and intellectual possibilities. | The devaluation of human originality through mass products:** Simanowski fears that machine-generated content could devalue the authenticity and originality of human creativity. As early as 2023, Schulte-Huermann warned of the "dangers of mass products in the AI sector" [[DOCREF:Die_Zukunft_mit_KI_müssen_wir_jetzt_die_Weichen_stellen.pdf]], which threaten the uniqueness of human beings. The question is not whether creativity will change, but whether it will remain genuinely human or degrade us to passive consumers. | Genuine creativity lies in human intentionality and experience.** AI must serve as a tool that enhances human expression, not replaces it. Clear guidelines for transparency and labeling preserve the value of human originality. Humans act as curators, visionaries and the ones who create meaning. Schulte-Huermann's call for "individually trained, personality-tailored AI systems" is an important approach here. |
| 2 | GenAI as an efficiency booster for knowledge: Generative AI accelerates scientific discovery and improves collaboration through efficient information synthesis and access [[DOCREF:Study protocol final Annex 1.pdf], [DOCREF:Study protocol final Annex 2.pdf]]. | The risk of epistemic erosion - the "greed is cool" trap of knowledge and the flood of data:** Language machines generate convincing but potentially false content ("hallucinations") that blur the distinction between truth and fiction. This leads to an "epistemic erosion" and a fundamental loss of trust in information. Similar to the "greed is cool" campaign, which established a false premise and led to devaluation in the long term, we are threatened here by a social acceptance of "cheap", unverified knowledge [[DOCREF:Study protocol final Annex 2.pdf]]. As early as 2023, Schulte-Huermann spoke of the "excessive demands placed on humanity by the current flood of data and ambiguity", which can lead to psychological stress [[DOCREF:Die_Zukunft_mit_KI_müssen_wir_jetzt_die_Weichen_stellen.pdf]]. Efficiency becomes a trap when it comes at the expense of truth. | The integrity of knowledge must be a top priority.** This requires robust verification mechanisms (e.g. RAG principle), transparent citation of sources and the promotion of critical thinking. We must prioritize the value of validated knowledge over mere availability and resist the seduction of quick, unvalidated "knowledge". |
| 3 Robotics as an extension of human capabilities: Robotics and AI relieve tedious work and extend human capabilities, creating new opportunities for development and self-realization. Language models are a step towards even more capable, physically interacting systems. | The redefinition of human identity and the loss of autonomy:** When robots take over not only physical but also cognitive tasks that were once considered the core of human intelligence, human identity is fundamentally challenged. The question of "why am I" becomes more pressing when machines emulate our abilities and we delegate our autonomy and judgment to them. We risk becoming passive recipients of a world designed by machines. Schulte-Huermann's warning against "singularism" and the need to "protect human uniqueness" is crucial here [[DOCREF:Die_Zukunft_mit_KI_müssen_wir_jetzt_die_Weichen_stellen.pdf]]. | Human-centered robotics requires conscious design: Robots should serve as a supplement that supports humans in their development rather than replacing or disempowering them. This requires an ongoing social debate, the establishment of a strict ethical framework and the strengthening of human maturity in the face of technology. Schulte-Huermann's appeal to "place ethical and moral aspects at the forefront of AI development" is the way forward. |
Knodge.eu: A European anchor in the epistemic crisis?
Amidst these philosophical challenges and practical warnings, Knodge.eu offers an approach that attempts to directly address some of the issues raised by Simanowski and echo Schulte-Huermann's calls. It is not a universal solution to all philosophical dilemmas, but it is a pragmatic step towards a more responsible use of AI:
- Precision versus hallucination: Knodge.eu relies on the Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) principle to provide precise and valid answers based on the user's own, verified data [[DOCREF:2026-01-27_09-41.md]]. This is a direct counter to the "greed is cool" mentality of knowledge by prioritizing quality and traceability over mere generativity. It reduces the epistemic uncertainty created by unreliable AI outputs and supports the integrity of knowledge that both Simanowski and Schulte-Huermann call for.
Controlled action instead of blind automation: The Science Context Protocol (SCP) enables Knodge.eu to not only interpret data, but also trigger actions - for example, controlling machines or robots [[DOCREF:2026-01-27_09-41.md]]. When epistemic uncertainty is high, SCP can retrieve relevant protocols or expert knowledge to enable the robot to make an informed decision. This promotes a controlled, knowledge-based interaction and prevents an unreflective delegation of judgments to the machine [[DOCREF:2512.24189v1.pdf]].
Data protection as the foundation of trust and protection of individuality: With an isolated, EU-based infrastructure, zero logging and zero training, Knodge.eu ensures the highest data protection standards [[DOCREF:2026-01-27_09-41.md]]. This is a decisive step against the opacity of many language engines and creates a trustworthy environment that protects the integrity of the data and thus the knowledge. By leaving data sovereignty with the user, it also indirectly supports the development of "individually trained, personality-tailored AI systems", as called for by Schulte-Huermann, without compromising privacy. The Secure Copy Protocol (SCP) also ensures secure and encrypted data transmission and software deployments for robotics applications [[DOCREF:portal-memory-scp und robotic-2026-01-13.pdf], [DOCREF:wie-kann-meta-ros-und-scp-sich_2026-02-01.md]].
The future of robotics and AI will not only be determined by technological progress, but also by our ability to understand the philosophical implications and set ethical guardrails. Knodge.eu offers an approach that seeks to harness the benefits of AI without compromising the integrity of knowledge and the autonomy of humans. It is an attempt to shape the "language machines" not as masters, but as responsible tools, and to set the course for a human future with AI.
Bibliography:
| Document ID | Title |
|---|---|
| (External) | Simanowski, R. (2023). Language machines: The emancipation of language from the human mind. C.H.Beck. |
| [[DOCREF:A_Review_of_Uncertainty_Representation_a.pdf]] | Wang, K., Cuzzolin, F., Shariatmadar, K., Moens, D., & Hallez, H. (2025). A Review of Uncertainty Representation and Quantification in Neural Networks. IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence. DOI: 10.1109/TPAMI.2025.3626645 |
| [[DOCREF:Die_Zukunft_mit_KI_müssen_wir_jetzt_die_Weichen_stellen.pdf]] | [Schulte-Huermann, M. (2023). *The future with AI: do we need to set the course now? LinkedIn Pulse]](https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/die-zukunft-mit-ki-m%C3%BCssen-wir-jetzt-die-weichen-stellen-markus-schulte-huermann) |
| [[DOCREF:humanoid_report_2026_v19-jwxa0v.pdf]] | (Unknown). The Humanoid Robot Market 2025/2026: Everything You Need To Know. |
| [[DOCREF:international-ai-safety-report-2026.pdf]] | Bengio, Y., Clare, S., Prunkl, C., et al. (2026). INTERNATIONAL AI SAFETY REPORT 2026. International AI Safety Report. |
| [[DOCREF:Lister of Robotoic Manufacturers.pdf]] | (Unknown). Portal knowledge base. |
| [[DOCREF:portal-memory-blogartikel-2026-01-26.md]] | (2026). Europe's robotics champions: A look at the leading companies. |
| [[DOCREF:portal-memory-humanoid-robot-manufacturers-europe-2026-01-13.pdf]] | (Unknown). Portal Knowledge Base: Humanoid Robots Manufacturers Europe. |
| [[DOCREF:2026-01-27_09-41.md]] | (Unknown). Knodge.eu: A European Knowledge Hub for Adaptive AI Systems and the Science Context Protocol. |
| [[DOCREF:2512.24189v1.pdf]] | Jiang, Y., Lu, J., Lou, W., et al. (Unknown). SCP: Accelerating Discovery with a Global Web of Autonomous Scientific Agents. arXiv:2512.24189v1 |
| [[DOCREF:portal-memory-scp and robotic-2026-01-13.pdf]] | (2026). Portal knowledge base: SCP for robotics. |
| [[DOCREF:wie-kann-meta-ros-und-scp-sich_2026-02-01.md]] | (Unknown). How Meta-ROS and SCP can complement each other. |
| [[DOCREF:portal-memory-RAG Nested Learning-2026-01-10.pdf]] | (Unknown). Portal knowledge base. |
| [[DOCREF:Study protocol final Annex 1.pdf]] | Annex 1: Results of the desk research |
| [[DOCREF:Study protocol final Annex 2.pdf]] | Annex 2: Results of step 2a - Scenario collection |
| [[DOCREF:_user_Aktuelle_Entwicklungen_Robotik_Juni_2026.md]] | Current developments in robotics (June 2026) |
| (External) | Robotics News, Analysis & Research - The Robot Report |
| (External) | News Archives - Humanoid robot guide |
| (External) | Humanoid robots: - Vietnam.vn |
| (External) | Robot Technologies: News and Product Announcements |
| (External) | Latest Robotics News - Business Leaders Review |
| (External) | The Robot Report |
| (External) | Humanoid robot guide |
| (External) | Robotics Research Papers - arXiv cs.RO Daily Feed |
| (External) | News Archives - Page 8 of 30 - Humanoid robot guide |
| (External) | Robotics News & Trends 2026 |
| (External) | Robotics Business News |
| (External) | Humanoid Robots 2026: Who's really ahead - and when they'll be in our homes |
| (External) | Robotics - arXiv |
| (External) | Robot Technologies: News and Product Announcements |
| (External) | Humanoid Robots 2025 - Market Overview of the Top Models - Automation NEXT |
| (External) | Humanoid Blog: Robotics News and Industry Insights |
| (External) | The Robot Report Enewsletter |
| (External) | While Europe is still testing, China's humanoid robots are already working in factories |
| (External) | Robotics Business Review: Contact Information, Journalists, and Overview - Muck Rack |
| (External) | Insights & Opinions - Robotics Business News |
| (External) | Humanoid Robots News |
| (External) | The New Generation: Why Humanoid Robots Will Change Everything by 2030 |
| (External) | Robotics - arXiv |
| (External) | Robotics Jun 2026 - arXiv |
| (External) | Robotics - arXiv |
| (External) | IEEE Spectrum - IEEE Robotics and Automation Society Website |
| (External) | News - IEEE Robotics and Automation Society Website |
| (External) | Humanoid Robots: AI and Mechatronics Revolution at IEEE-RAS 2024 Conference |
| (External) | IEEE Innovation Spotlight: Building Robots for Uncertain Terrain - YouTube |
| (External) | State Estimation for Hybrid Wheeled-Legged Robots Performing Mobile Manipulation Tasks |